Continuing the Western motif of Way Out West, Sonny Rollins takes on Peter DeRose's 1934 cowboy song "Wagon Wheels" with the same irreverent wit he brought to "I'm an Old Cowhand." The 44-bar AABAC form is one of the more unusual structures on the album, and Rollins navigates its contours across three inventive choruses at a medium-swing tempo. His solo demonstrates his renowned ability to develop short melodic motifs through repetition, variation, and rhythmic displacement, constructing long, logically connected melodic narratives from simple thematic cells. Ray Brown contributes a full chorus of bass improvisation, his walking lines and melodic statements enriched by the acoustic clarity of the Contemporary Records studio. Shelly Manne rounds out the solo sequence with a partial drum chorus that highlights his musical sensitivity and impeccable taste. The track is another example of the album's conceptual boldness: by choosing material associated with cowboys and the American West, Rollins challenged the notion that jazz musicians could only draw from a narrow canon of Tin Pan Alley standards and bebop originals. The result is music that is simultaneously humorous and deeply serious, a hallmark of Rollins's artistic vision.